饿……睡了一觉以后还在思考这两部电影，觉得身为一个科学工作者，凡事都要讲究客观。虽说电影这东西对我来说本就一个消遣，但是难得如此认真的写一次影评，而且有无间道有那么大的先入为主的主观优势，那就心平气和地看看别人是怎么看这两部电影的。
于是去了IMDB看看那些把TD评为奥斯卡的米国观众是怎么评的………
尤其是要看别人怎么批评它的才能看的比较客观
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0407887/usercomments?filter=hate
看的我那个热泪盈眶啊，原来有那么多看了电影还忍不住写那么老长的文章去骂的，还写了很多我都懒得去说的情节漏洞……
再看看别人是怎么批评无间道的……
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0338564/usercomments?filter=hate
很多人评论说关于这两个卧底怎么成长的描写的太含糊了，对此我只能建议这些同学去看看无间道II....10年的卧底生涯啊，你要怎么个交代得清清楚楚明明白白还不显得累赘，原片中那简洁的风格实在是足够了，反倒是那个花了半个小时想把各自怎么打入敌方内部的TD陷入了一些很明显的情节漏洞，卧底4个月黑帮老大就和你掏心掏肺死了还把证据都寄给你？当警察4个月就能一路高升到全权负责查卧底的职位？画虎不成反类犬啊……
尤其是这篇……实在忍不住贴出来嘲笑一下，居然有看片智商比我还低的人敢出来写影评……勇气可嘉勇气可嘉……
Hard to understand,
2 August 2005 3/10
Author: menastra from United States
I found the film very hard to understand. Although the acting was good I had trouble understanding the plot. Who is the good guy,who is the bad guy,who is he talking to?（这位同学的世界观是多么的单纯……不是好人就是坏人……） That sort of thing. I did not know if I was looking at a thriller about the use of cell phones in solving crimes or a story about two men trying to figure out their way in the world.
I was also upset with the cop in the mob not figuring out who the mole was in the police department despite the fact that he saw the mole talking with the mob boss in the theater. Why did the cop allow a his cell phone to go off when he was after the mole leaving the theater?（这里的确是我比较不喜欢的地方，但TD里不还是一样，不但没改进还更糟）
How did the cop sell the mole audio equipment at the start of the film?(哎……我不知道米国的黑帮是咋样的，但是连这也看不懂……我实在是无话可说了……顺便提一下，TD里为啥诺大一个黑帮老大在片头还自己上门收保护费?) All in all I saw the DVD version of the film because I heard that the film was being made into a American version. Mostly I was disappointed in the film.Hopfully the American director will explain the plot twists better. (只能说……American Director拍得太让人遗憾了……)
写到这里，觉得还是淡定一下吧。该写的主要问题都写了，再下去就是估计纯发泄的骂人了……淡定淡定，干活去……
